Peanuts are not sweet unless sugar is added. This is good peanut butter, it does not separate and tasted like fresh roasted nuts. I have had peanuts straight from the field and oven roasted them, this is just as good. The slight sweetness from the molasses makes it my all time favorite. The bad part is the cost.

I did stir - very well - and this product still tasted like fish oil. I have never hated a brand of peanut butter prior to making this purchase. Nutritional stats are good, so I wanted to give it a try - never again.

This tastes like eating fish oil capsules which is quite repulsive. I don't know how the managed to do this as it has sunflower and flax oil neither of which taste fishy to me.

I don't often review products, but after buying this peanut butter and discovering its strangely fishy taste, I felt the need to search "Smart Balance Peanut Butter fish" with Google. Sure enough, plenty of consumers agree that this peanut butter tastes like fish. It's likely the five star reviews you see on this and other sites are paid for by GFA Brands, as it doesn't seem possible that anyone could miss the fishy taste, which closely resembles fish oil capsules. You may also notice that most of the positive reviews here and elsewhere take the, "That other reviewer is crazy," approach. Another clue that these reviews probably aren't real.

I love the nutritional benefits of this product, but the taste is awful. It has a fishy flavor. I've eaten plenty of natural peanut butters that have great taste, but this one is just gross.

I do not know what they did to the poor peanut butter to give it this flavor. It is lightly fishy, highly oversalted, and lacking any real sweetness at all. It seems less sweet than raw peanuts.This stuff was too unpalatable for any use I can conceive of, and we had to throw it away. We tried the 'creamy' style of this product.