I liked the movie and the directing was good. I did not like the unhappy ending. You did feel somewhat better when he was traveling after his death. it is believable.

I liked the movie, I thought it was cute, although sometimes sad, but overall I think the movie came together nicely without all of the long, long irrelevant descriptions in the book. The book was very drawn out and got on my nerves. In the movie the characters are actually likeable, unlike the book. I would recommend watching the movie but not reading the book.

this movie was so slow and boring i fell asleep and didn't care that i missed parts of it,don't waste your time.it was just plain dumb.

We saw this on an American Airlines flight last December. The premise was intriguing, but their were so many incongruencies and continuity errors, that the film was rather trying and rather unenjoyable.

THE MOVIE SEEMED VERY THROWN TOGETHER. IF YOUR LOOKING FOR ANOTHER STORY LIKE THE NOTEBOOK, ITS NOT THIS ONE.

The book was one of the best books I've ever read. This movie was so disappointing, didn't even come close to the book.